Private Dining in Brooklyn: Rooms Compared by Capacity
Private dining in Brooklyn compared by capacity: nine restaurants with rooms for 8 to 400 guests, Al Di La's published minimums and what to ask before booking.
Al Di La is the only one of nine Brooklyn restaurants compared for private dining whose event page prints both a per-person dinner price and a spending minimum: 75 dollars a head for three courses, and $4,000 Monday to Thursday or $5,000 Friday and Saturday. The rooms run from a third-floor room for 8 to 16 guests at Sunday in Brooklyn in Williamsburg (per its 2025 events deck) to a Marble Room that Gargiulo’s in Coney Island lists for up to 400. Capacities, fees and policies below come from each restaurant’s own website and event documents, checked in October 2026.
Which Brooklyn restaurants have private rooms, from Williamsburg to Coney Island?
Each of the nine prints a guest count or range for private events, and the table is ordered by the largest figure each prints, smallest first. Five describe their cooking as Italian: Al Di La, Lilia, Aurora, Leuca at The William Vale and Gargiulo’s. Kokomo is Caribbean.
| Restaurant | Address | Best for | Key verified detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Al Di La | 248 5th Ave | A seated dinner for 25 | Wine bar area: 25 floor seats plus 8 bar seats; minimum $4,000 Mon-Thu, $5,000 Fri-Sat |
| Kokomo | 65 Kent Ave, Williamsburg | Themed rooms, prix fixe | Lovers Rock 24, Paradise Room 32, Champagne Room 38 (unlabeled) |
| Lilia | 567 Union Ave, Williamsburg | A shared dinner for 12 to 20 | Semi-private room 12-20; buyout “~85” |
| Aurora | 70 Grand St, Williamsburg | Seated or cocktails | 80 seated / 100 cocktail reception; patio 50 (home page: up to 100) |
| Gage & Tollner | 372 Fulton St, Downtown Brooklyn | Landmarked parlor rooms | Edna Lewis Room 35-40 seated / 45 standing; Dolphin Bar 22 / 30; main dining room 100 seated |
| The River Café | One Water St | Harbor and bridge views | Terrace Room; events of “30 to 100 guests” |
| Sunday in Brooklyn | 348 Wythe Ave, Williamsburg | Rooms for 8 to 50, or a buyout | Page: 9 to 150. 2025 deck: rooms 8-16 and up to 50; whole restaurant 120 seated / 150 standing |
| The William Vale | 111 N 12th St, Williamsburg | Dinner for 30, or a rooftop for 220 | Leuca Private Dining Room 30; Westlight 220; Vale Ballroom 320 |
| Gargiulo’s | 2911 West 15th St, Coney Island | Eight rooms | Board Room up to 25 through Marble Room up to 400 (weddings page: 500) |
Barbuto Brooklyn is left out: its page offers “a variety of options” and a form, with no count.
How much does private dining cost per person in Brooklyn?
One of the nine event pages prints a per-person dinner price. Al Di La’s is a pre-selected three-course dinner in its wine bar area for 75 dollars per person (the page prints “75$”), food only, with drinks charged as consumed, plus 8.875% tax, 20% gratuity and a 3.5% card processing fee. The minimum is $4,000 Monday to Thursday and $5,000 Friday and Saturday, any shortfall becomes a room fee, and extra event time costs $500 per hour. For 25 seated guests the food comes to 1,875 dollars, so a Monday-to-Thursday party needs 2,125 dollars more in drinks to reach the minimum, and a Friday or Saturday party 3,125 dollars. The page does not say whether tax and gratuity count toward it.
The William Vale prints a structure and no dollar figure: pricing is “treated as a food & beverage minimum,” or a room rental fee if food and beverage is not required, plus 8.875% sales tax and a 24% administrative fee. Kokomo sends “options and pricing” after an inquiry, and its FAQ says a 20% gratuity is added automatically to checks for parties of 2 or more. Sunday in Brooklyn’s deck mentions a food and beverage minimum “if applicable” without a figure. Gargiulo’s brochure leaves its menu and package price lines blank or too faint to read; the one legible dollar figure on its bar page is a cap of $25 per person on a wine and beer reception, so ask for the prices. Gage & Tollner, The River Café, Lilia and Aurora print no price or minimum on the pages checked. Confirm every figure with each events coordinator.
How many guests fit in a Brooklyn private dining room?
Plan a dinner to the seated number. Only three of the nine print both a seated and a standing or cocktail figure: Gage & Tollner room by room, Aurora for its space as a whole, and Sunday in Brooklyn for its whole restaurant. Al Di La prints seating alone, and the other five print guest counts without saying how the room is set. Where both exist the gap is modest: Gage & Tollner’s Dolphin Bar holds 30 standing against 22 seated (a ratio of 1.36), Aurora’s 100 over 80 is 1.25, and Sunday in Brooklyn’s whole restaurant is 1.25 in summer and fall and 1.20 in winter and spring.
Best for 8 to 25 guests
Sunday in Brooklyn’s web page says it takes groups of 9 to 150, while its 2025 events deck gives the third-floor private dining room as 8 to 16, so a party of 8 is a question to ask. The deck also lists a rooftop Garden for 16 to 24 and says the private dining room, Garden and Sun Room are reached by stairs only. Lilia’s semi-private room takes 12 to 20 and its a la carte tables up to 6, leaving 7 to 11 guests unaddressed. Al Di La’s wine bar area seats 25 plus 8 at the bar, and Gargiulo’s Board Room is listed at up to 25.
Best for 26 to 60 guests
Gage & Tollner’s Edna Lewis Room seats 35 to 40, and joined to the Dolphin Bar through original sliding pocket doors the two seat 60. The William Vale lists the Leuca Private Dining Room at 30. Sunday in Brooklyn’s Sun Room (up to 50) and Aurora’s enclosed patio (up to 50, bookable without a full buyout) fill the upper end. Aurora’s home page says its patio “can accommodate up to 100 guests, depending on the occasion”, so ask which number applies.
Best for 61 to 150 guests
Aurora seats up to 80, and Lilia’s buyout tops out at about 85. Gage & Tollner lists its main dining room at 100 seated and the full second floor at 100 standing. The River Café’s events page cites special events and corporate dinners of 30 to 100 guests for its Terrace Room without saying how the room is set, and its footer reads 1977-2024, so confirm the range. Sunday in Brooklyn’s deck gives its whole restaurant as 120 seated and 150 standing in summer and fall, and 100 and 120 in winter and spring. Gargiulo’s Belvedere A lists 75 to 120 and its Waterfall Room 100 to 140.
Best for more than 150 guests
Only two of the nine publish a space above 150: The William Vale (Westlight, the 23rd Floor and Vale Terrace at 220 each, Vale Park 300, Vale Ballroom 320) and Gargiulo’s Marble Room, up to 400. Neither says whether those figures are seated or standing, so ask for the seated number. Gargiulo’s weddings page mentions “grand receptions for 500 guests”, against 400 on its private events page. For scale, the largest seated buyout in the Midtown comparison, private dining in Midtown NYC by published capacity, is 200.
Which Brooklyn room suits which kind of party?
- A harbor view with a dress code: The River Café’s Terrace Room overlooks New York Harbor, the Brooklyn Bridge and the Manhattan skyline; jackets and collared shirts are required for gentlemen, and casual jeans, athletic attire and sandals are not permitted.
- A rooftop above Williamsburg: The William Vale’s 23rd Floor is described as having views of the 5 boroughs.
- A historic room: Gage & Tollner’s Edna Lewis Room and Dolphin Bar sit in a landmarked building, restored in the style of Victorian parlors. Its Sunken Harbor Club holds 25 standing and is not conducive to seated affairs.
- An Italian dinner: Lilia, Al Di La, Aurora, Leuca and Gargiulo’s all publish counts. For six or fewer, a sister publication lists Italian restaurants in Brooklyn worth booking for a regular table.
How far ahead should you book a Brooklyn private room?
Only Kokomo’s event pages print a lead time: fill out the event form 1 to 2 weeks before the event and allow 48 hours for a reply. A booking is confirmed when the contract is signed and the deposit paid; the balance is charged 24 hours before the event, and a party-size decrease needs five days’ notice. Parties under 18 guests get 2 hours and buyouts of 18 or more get 3. Its rooms list no capacity above 38, yet buyouts are required from 18 guests, so ask whether a buyout means one room or the restaurant.
The other eight print none: Gage & Tollner takes a form, Al Di La an email and Gargiulo’s a tour or information request. Kokomo’s FAQ lists Monday through Wednesday as closed and Gargiulo’s lists Tuesday, so ask about event days. The note on how a changing headcount affects the contract pairs with Kokomo’s five-day rule.
Frequently asked questions
How much does private dining cost per person in Brooklyn?
Among nine Brooklyn restaurants with published private rooms, only Al Di La prints a per-person dinner price: 75 dollars for three courses, food only, with a minimum of $4,000 Monday to Thursday and $5,000 Friday and Saturday. The William Vale prints a 24% administrative fee and 8.875% sales tax but no dollar amounts, as of October 2026.
What restaurants in Brooklyn have private rooms?
This guide compares nine: Al Di La, Kokomo, Lilia, Aurora, Gage & Tollner, The River Café, Sunday in Brooklyn, The William Vale (with the Leuca Private Dining Room) and Gargiulo’s. It is a selection, not a complete list.
How many people fit in a Brooklyn private dining room?
The smallest published room is Sunday in Brooklyn’s third-floor private dining room at 8 to 16 guests per its 2025 events deck, and the largest is Gargiulo’s Marble Room at up to 400 (its weddings page cites receptions for 500). Between them, Gage & Tollner’s Edna Lewis Room seats 35 to 40 and holds 45 standing, as of October 2026.
Where can you book private dining in Williamsburg or Downtown Brooklyn?
In Williamsburg, Kokomo, Lilia, Aurora, Sunday in Brooklyn and The William Vale each publish room sizes. In Downtown Brooklyn, Gage & Tollner at 372 Fulton Street lists rooms from 22 to 100 seated. The River Café at One Water Street, riverside under the Brooklyn Bridge, cites events of 30 to 100 guests in its Terrace Room.


